weve had both the 1.8 and the 2.2. both were great. the 1.8 we never had a problem with in fact wed probably still have it now if it weren't written off. the 2.2 is a beautiful car to drive. very comfortable and very responsive. its nice cause you can drive it like a grandmother to save petrol and get decent economy out of it and has enough power to give a bit of fun when you put your foot down. but as was mentioned before. don't suggest a car. what id say is give them a sample of cars (just photos and positives and negatives of each) to choose from. let them choose what they like then find them a few of those cars to look at.